Domes are one of the most efficient shapes in the world since it covers the maximum volume with the minimum surface area. Maintaining larger volumes with no interrupting columns in the middle with an efficient shape would be more efficient and economic. So, the use of domes will help having larger volumes with no interrupting in the middle.
Romans demonstrated the structural potential of the dome shape. By using a form of concrete in horizontal layers, they constructed the Pantheon with the dome above with a span of 44 meters diameter. It is still the biggest span of the dome structures in the world even today.
Case Study 1: Santa Maria del Fiore (Florence Cathedral)
Background Information
Architect: Arnolfo di Cambio (the cathedral) Filippo Brunelleschi (the dome)
Placement: Florence, Italy
Construction date: 1296 - 1436 - Construction of the whole cathedral.
1420 - 1436 - Construction of the dome. Span: 42 meters diameter.
Height: It is mentioned as the half of its diameter; so it is about 21 meters.
Structural properties: It has 8 vertical ribs stiffened with horizontal elements.
The construction of the dome of Florence Cathedral was one of the germinal events of Renaissance architecture. The problem had been posed in the middle of the fourteenth century when the definitive plan for the octagonal crossing had been laid down.
In 1418, a competition of model was held in order to solve the octagonal dome of the Florence Cathedral. Filippo Brunelleschi’s model was chosen the first. It was formed by steep stone arches whose inside was filled with bricks. This construction didn’t have to have a scaffold as usual, so it brought a new construction technique to the architecture. Old Romans had developed this technique, and probably Brunelleschi had seen it at the old buildings of Romans.The construction began at 1420 and finished at 1436.
The Exterior
The Basilica di Santa Maria del Fiore is the main church of Florence, Italy. It begun in 1296 in the gothic style to the design of Arnolfo di Cambrio and completed structurally in 1436 with the dome engineered by Filippo Brunelleschi. The exterior of the basilica, a public building of ancient Rome which was used as a courtroom or assembly hall, is faced with polychrome marble panels in various shades of green and pink bordered by white and has an elaborate 19th-century Gothic Revival façade by Emilio de Fabris.
Gothic Revival:
Gothic Revival was one of the most influential styles of the 19th century. Designs were based on forms and patterns used in the Middle Ages. Serious study was combined with a more fanciful, romantic vision of Medieval chivalry and romance.
Saint Clotilde Basilica, Washington National Cathedral and Parlement de Rouen.
The Façade
In 1864, a competition was held to design a new façade and was won by Emilio De Fabris (1808–1883) in 1871. Work began in 1876 and completed in 1887. The eye-catching façade of Florence's Duomo is made of polychrome panels of green, white, and red marble. But this design is not the original. Earlier Duomo designs by Arnolfo di Cambio, Giotto, and Bernardo Buontalenti are on view at the Museo del Opera del Duomo (the Duomo Museum).The whole façade is dedicated to the Mother of Christ.


The Dome
In the beginning, the Romans used a type of concrete to construct the dome of Pantheon in 118-128 A.C. And its span was 44 m. with a coffered structure. At the dome, the friction is increased by the help of the concrete used here. So the dome has a very large span and it still stands for more than 2000 years. The architects of Pantheon knew the forces and science very well and most probably they reached this knowledge by observing the ancient buildings around them.
In 1420-1436, Brunelleschi constructed the dome of Florence Cathedral, having 8 ribs. Its diameter was 42 m. (from corner to corner). The ribs are supported by beams at three levels. The filling between these ribs and beams is brick which is light in weight. Brunelleschi knew well that ribs and beams carry the main loads, and the filling only covers the dome. So it does not have to be very heavy, it must be light in order to lower the loads carried by the ribs and beams. Brunelleschi learned these rules in his visits he made to the ancient structures and buildings around Europe. So, it is really important and necessary to look at the historical constructions in order to learn what their designers know. Then it would be easier to find the best and the most efficient solution to our problems in construction.
Case Study 2: The Pantheon
Architect: M. Vispanius Agrippa, Emperor Hadrian
Placement: Rome, Italy
Construction date: 27 B.C. -first constructed by M. Vispanius Agrippa.
118-128 A.C. -repaired by Emperor Hadrian.
Span: 44 meter diameter. Height: It is nearly 45 meters as calculated from the section drawing. Structural Properties: It is a coffered dome. There are 28 vertical, 5 horizontal ribs in the coffers.
The Pantheon was a temple in honor of the Olympic gods; in fact, the word pantheon is Greek for "of all the gods." It is the best-preserved of all the Roman monuments. The original Pantheon was constructed by M. Vispanius Agrippa in 27 B.C. The Pantheon we see today, however, is a reconstruction built by the Emperor Hadrian, perhaps after a fire. In A.D. 609, Pope Boniface VIII received the building as a gift from the emperor of Byzantium. He made it into a Christian church dedicated it to the Madonna and the martyrs.
This is the biggest dome of its kind in the world even now in 2001. A form of concrete was used at the construction of this dome; because of this, it still stands today. But when the concrete technology was lost, even though many domes were constructed of stone and timber, the limitations of weight and jointing techniques restricted their spanning potential.
The Interior
The interior of the dome was possibly intended to symbolize the arched vault of the heavens. The building design is one of a large round shape very much like a large barrel with a dome covering the top. There is a light-well in the center of the dome. Layers of beautiful thin brickwork cover the outside, round walls. Small access holes appear occasionally in the wall which were used during construction to frame interior voids.
The main entrance is thoroughly impressive: double bronze doors 21 feet high which are protected by a high, broad porch, made with 16 well arranged granite columns supporting a gable styled roof. The beams in the roof structure of the porch are wooden. They were substituted for bronze members stripped-out by those in later years needing metal for their canons.Professional Roman surveyors located the inlaid marble floor to conform with a convex contour which drained away the rain from the oculus for these hundreds of years.'
Foundation
The Pantheon was built on marshy, unstable earth hence they built a second ring to hold the first ring from cracking further and to give the clay more area to support the structure. It worked because the building has lasted over 1800 years. In addition to keeping the crack from extending, the builders placed buttress walls on the south side opposite the massive porch. This acted as a clamping device.
The Dome
On the outside surface, there is a series of seven step- rings half way up the dome, and then the dome line changes into a circular line. On the inside surface the dome contains a series of 5 bands made of waffle-like depressions called coffers. There are 140 coffers which required special forming for the waffle shape. At mid-point the dome contour changes from these coffers to a circular line. In the center of the dome is a large opening, the oculus.The outside rings are not uniform, there are 7 rings.
When we went to the Pantheon itself to investigate, we realized that the oculus can be used for natural lighting, as well as a sundial to tell time.